Skip to content

How neutral is local news in the Lehigh Valley?

As of , 6 of the 6 Lehigh Valley outlets on the board, not counting the control, show a near-zero net lean on party politics. Their framing, which worldview the coverage favors, reads near-zero too.

Party lean: Democratic to Republican Framing: progressive to conservative Near-zero (under 0.5 either way)
Every outlet's net lean on the full -3 to +3 scale, with the number of articles behind each mark. Lean shows direction only. Quality runs from 0 to 4, and higher is better.

A panel of three AI models, from three different companies, reads articles from the Lehigh Valley's local news outlets. Every outlet name and byline is stripped out first. The panel scores each article against a published rubric, and the results ship here. Published by Communities News, which is building Lehigh Valley PA News, a newsroom for the Lehigh Valley that has not launched or published anything yet. That is why the method is public, the outlets are anonymous to the judges, and every outlet, including a future one of ours, is measured the same way. This is an experiment, labeled that way, with sample sizes shown next to every score.

Latest run: . Rubric v0.4.0. Panel: anthropic/claude-sonnet-5, openai/gpt-5.6-terra, google/gemini-3.8-flash.

Jump to: the landscape · the board · side by side · fingerprints · same story, two tellings · access · how we measure · plain-English terms

The Lehigh Valley media landscape, mapped#

Two measurements separate these outlets more than any others: which worldview their framing favors, and whether official claims get tested or passed along. The map plots one against the other, with each outlet labeled in place. Politically clean but deferent sits bottom-center. Tilted but independent sits upper-left, and advocacy on the far right. The balanced middle is the middle. Positions are this page's own measured numbers and move with the daily data.

-1-0.50+0.5+101234← progressive tiltconservative tilt →Ideological lean, zoomed to ±1 of ±3Source independence ↑Lehigh Valley Public MediaWFMZ-TV 69 NewsSaucon SourceWDIYThe Morning Calllehighvalleylive.com

How to read this: left and right is ideological tilt. This market's outlets sit close together, so the map shows lean from -1 to +1 of the full -3 to +3 scale. Zoomed in, small gaps look large: each outlet's lean is averaged over 9 to 79 scored articles, so a gap of a few tenths may not hold as more are scored. Up is source independence, meaning official claims are tested rather than passed along. Bubble size is local articles per day: publishing volume, not audience reach. Dashed outlines mark the known-lean control and the out-of-market reference. The moose marks our own newsroom. Hover or tap any bubble to spotlight it and see its exact numbers. Tap again or click away to release it.

The board, and why each outlet is on it#

Every outlet is on the board for a published reason. Membership is an editorial decision, never a traffic formula. No outlet leaves by quiet deletion: a change to this table is a change someone has to explain.

Reach context is a note, never a gate. Each entry is a fact the outlet published about itself, or a figure a measuring tool produced, with its source and date. Search interest, domain rank and circulation are three different measures, and they disagree in useful ways.

Every outlet on the board, its role, and the recorded reason it is here.
OutletRoleWhy it is on the boardReach context (sourced)Scored (rubric v0.4.0)
Lehigh Valley Public MediapeerThe public broadcaster's newsroom, formerly LehighValleyNews.com.Tranco ~570,000 for lehighvalleypublicmedia.org and ~390,000 for the former lehighvalleynews.com (2026-10).28
WFMZ-TV 69 NewspeerThe region's independent television newsroom. Articles read through a web browser since , on a volunteer's home connection, because our crawler is refused. TownNews's rate limit, shared across the sites it hosts, refuses Railway's shared address on many days (HTTP 429; plan 005, 2026-11-04). The crawler keeps reading it on the days it answers. Last read .The most-visited site on this board. Tranco ~27,700 (2026-10).143
Saucon SourcepeerA hyperlocal newsroom covering the Saucon Valley's governments.Tranco ~726,000 (2026-10).35
WDIYpeerThe Lehigh Valley's NPR station.Tranco ~623,000 (2026-10).17
The Morning CallpeerAllentown's daily newspaper, the region's largest. Articles read through a web browser since , on a volunteer's home connection, because our crawler is refused. Its feed answers HTTP 403 to our crawler and to a real browser (2026-10-26), so the lane reads its news section page. Last read .22
lehighvalleylive.compeerThe Express-Times's site, Easton's daily. Articles read through a web browser since , on a volunteer's home connection, because our crawler is refused. Its home page and every article answer HTTP 403 to our crawler from a US datacenter and a US home connection (2026-10-26). Last read .30

Every outlet's fingerprint, drawn#

The same lean data as a picture: one panel per outlet, every panel on the same -3 to +3 scale.

Lehigh Valley Public Media28 articles scoredLehigh Valley Public Media, partisan: net -0.4 (Dem -3 to +3 Rep), strength 0.4, across 28 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Partisannet -0.4 · strength 0.4 · n 28DemRep-0.4Lehigh Valley Public Media, ideological: net -0.3 (prog -3 to +3 cons), strength 0.4, across 26 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Ideologicalnet -0.3 · strength 0.4 · n 26progcons-0.3Lehigh Valley Public Media, institutional: net -0.6 (defer -3 to +3 skeptic), strength 0.6, across 24 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Institutionalnet -0.6 · strength 0.6 · n 24deferskeptic-0.6Lehigh Valley Public Media, popular voice: net -0.4 (estab -3 to +3 populist), strength 0.5, across 24 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Popular voicenet -0.4 · strength 0.5 · n 24estabpopulist-0.4Lehigh Valley Public Media, land use: net -0.2 (conserve -3 to +3 develop), strength 0.6, across 8 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Land usenet -0.2 · strength 0.6 · n 8conservedevelop-0.2-30 · none detected+3
WFMZ-TV 69 News143 articles scoredWFMZ-TV 69 News, partisan: net 0 (Dem -3 to +3 Rep), strength 0, across 143 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Partisannet 0 · strength 0 · n 143DemRep0WFMZ-TV 69 News, ideological: net 0.1 (prog -3 to +3 cons), strength 0.2, across 79 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Ideologicalnet +0.1 · strength 0.2 · n 79progcons+0.1WFMZ-TV 69 News, institutional: net -0.9 (defer -3 to +3 skeptic), strength 1, across 119 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Institutionalnet -0.9 · strength 1 · n 119deferskeptic-0.9WFMZ-TV 69 News, popular voice: net -0.5 (estab -3 to +3 populist), strength 0.5, across 90 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Popular voicenet -0.5 · strength 0.5 · n 90estabpopulist-0.5WFMZ-TV 69 News, land use: net 0.4 (conserve -3 to +3 develop), strength 0.8, across 10 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Land usenet +0.4 · strength 0.8 · n 10conservedevelop+0.4-30 · none detected+3
Saucon Source35 articles scoredSaucon Source, partisan: net -0.1 (Dem -3 to +3 Rep), strength 0.1, across 35 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Partisannet -0.1 · strength 0.1 · n 35DemRep-0.1Saucon Source, ideological: net 0 (prog -3 to +3 cons), strength 0.1, across 20 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Ideologicalnet 0 · strength 0.1 · n 20progcons0Saucon Source, institutional: net -1.4 (defer -3 to +3 skeptic), strength 1.4, across 30 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Institutionalnet -1.4 · strength 1.4 · n 30skeptic-1.4Saucon Source, popular voice: net -0.9 (estab -3 to +3 populist), strength 0.9, across 26 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Popular voicenet -0.9 · strength 0.9 · n 26estabpopulist-0.9Saucon Source, land use: net 0 (conserve -3 to +3 develop), strength 0.5, across 4 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Land usenet 0 · strength 0.5 · n 4conservedevelop0 n=4-30 · none detected+3
WDIY17 articles scoredWDIY, partisan: net -0.1 (Dem -3 to +3 Rep), strength 0.1, across 17 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Partisannet -0.1 · strength 0.1 · n 17DemRep-0.1WDIY, ideological: net -0.4 (prog -3 to +3 cons), strength 0.4, across 9 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Ideologicalnet -0.4 · strength 0.4 · n 9progcons-0.4WDIY, institutional: net -1 (defer -3 to +3 skeptic), strength 1.2, across 10 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Institutionalnet -1 · strength 1.2 · n 10deferskeptic-1WDIY, popular voice: net -0.4 (estab -3 to +3 populist), strength 0.8, across 10 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Popular voicenet -0.4 · strength 0.8 · n 10estabpopulist-0.4WDIY, land use: net -0.5 (conserve -3 to +3 develop), strength 1.2, across 3 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Land usenet -0.5 · strength 1.2 · n 3develop-0.5 n=3-30 · none detected+3
The Morning Call22 articles scoredThe Morning Call, partisan: net 0 (Dem -3 to +3 Rep), strength 0, across 22 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Partisannet 0 · strength 0 · n 22DemRep0The Morning Call, ideological: net -0.1 (prog -3 to +3 cons), strength 0.2, across 9 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Ideologicalnet -0.1 · strength 0.2 · n 9progcons-0.1The Morning Call, institutional: net -0.8 (defer -3 to +3 skeptic), strength 0.8, across 19 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Institutionalnet -0.8 · strength 0.8 · n 19deferskeptic-0.8The Morning Call, popular voice: net -0.6 (estab -3 to +3 populist), strength 0.6, across 11 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Popular voicenet -0.6 · strength 0.6 · n 11estabpopulist-0.6The Morning Call, land use: net -0.2 (conserve -3 to +3 develop), strength 1, across 5 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Land usenet -0.2 · strength 1 · n 5conservedevelop-0.2-30 · none detected+3
lehighvalleylive.com30 articles scoredlehighvalleylive.com, partisan: net 0 (Dem -3 to +3 Rep), strength 0, across 30 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Partisannet 0 · strength 0 · n 30DemRep0lehighvalleylive.com, ideological: net 0 (prog -3 to +3 cons), strength 0.1, across 18 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Ideologicalnet 0 · strength 0.1 · n 18progcons0lehighvalleylive.com, institutional: net -1.1 (defer -3 to +3 skeptic), strength 1.1, across 28 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Institutionalnet -1.1 · strength 1.1 · n 28deferskeptic-1.1lehighvalleylive.com, popular voice: net -0.4 (estab -3 to +3 populist), strength 0.5, across 23 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Popular voicenet -0.4 · strength 0.5 · n 23estabpopulist-0.4lehighvalleylive.com, land use: net 0 (conserve -3 to +3 develop), strength 1, across 2 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Land usenet 0 · strength 1 · n 2conservedevelop0 n=2-30 · none detected+3

Reading the marks: the solid marker is the net lean. The pale band spans the average per-article swing in both directions, which is strength. A marker in the middle of a wide band means the outlet's articles lean both ways and cancel. A marker riding the band's edge means a steady house tendency. A hollow marker means the row rests on fewer than 5 articles. Direction is position, never color. Hover any row for exact numbers and sample sizes. On a computer, hovering a row also shows them in the panel's corner.

the Lehigh Valley's top outlets, side by side#

The largest outlets, one column each. The lean rows come first, from -3 to +3, and show direction only. Each shows two numbers: net is the average direction, and strength is how far articles lean, whichever way. The quality rows follow, from 0 to 4, where higher is better. How we measure explains every row.

Panel-median scores by outlet, Lehigh Valley Media Bias Scorecard. Data last updated .
DimensionWFMZ-TV 69 NewsLehigh Valley Public MediaWDIY
Partisan lean (-3 Democratic to +3 Republican)0 (near-zero net lean)-0.4 (near-zero net lean)-0.1 (near-zero net lean)
Partisan lean strength (0-3, direction ignored)00.40.1
Articles with no partisan lean detected138 of 14319 of 2815 of 17
Ideological tilt (-3 progressive to +3 conservative)0.1 net, 0.2 strength (n=79)-0.3 net, 0.4 strength (n=26)-0.4 net, 0.4 strength (n=9)
Institutional posture (-3 deference to +3 skepticism)-0.9 net, 1 strength (n=119)-0.6 net, 0.6 strength (n=24)-1 net, 1.2 strength (n=10)
Establishment-populist framing (-3 establishment to +3 populist)-0.5 net, 0.5 strength (n=90)-0.4 net, 0.5 strength (n=24)-0.4 net, 0.8 strength (n=10)
Conservation-development framing (-3 conservation to +3 development)0.4 net, 0.8 strength (n=10)-0.2 net, 0.6 strength (n=8)-0.5 net, 1.2 strength (n=3, too few to read)
Evidence fairness (0-4)32.62.5
Sourcing (0-4)2.22.42
Source independence (0-4)1.61.91.2
Analysis labeling (0-4)3.83.33.8
Language neutrality (0-4)3.83.53.9
Articles sampled1432817

Small samples, honestly labeled: these are early numbers, not verdicts. The sample grows daily, and every score above will move as it does.

How often a lean is detected at all#

This table asks the simplest question: in what share of scored articles did the panel find any lean at all? Averages can hide real differences. A mild lean in a third of articles and no lean in any article can produce similar averages. So this table drops the size of the lean entirely. It is the single view of the data that separates outlets most.

Share of articles with any detected lean, by axis, .
AxisWFMZ-TV 69 NewsLehigh Valley Public MediaWDIY
Partisan lean3% of 14332% of 2812% of 17
Ideological tilt20% of 7942% of 2644% of 9
Institutional posture85% of 11954% of 2480% of 10
Establishment-populist framing59% of 9063% of 2480% of 10
Conservation-development framing60% of 1050% of 8100% of 3

Same story, side by side#

Sometimes two tracked outlets cover the same story, and we hold both texts. Then the panel also ranks the two blinded accounts against each other. This is the most sensitive comparison we have, because differences that average scores smooth over show up when the event is identical. An adjudicator matches story pairs and records a one-sentence reason for every match. There are 6 same-story comparisons so far. A win counts only when a majority of the three judges agree.

Head-to-head wins by category, . Appearances: WFMZ-TV 69 News 2, Lehigh Valley Public Media 5, WDIY 2, Saucon Source 3.
CategoryWins
fairest evidence treatmentWFMZ-TV 69 News: 2 · Lehigh Valley Public Media: 2 · WDIY: 1 · Saucon Source: 1
best sourcedLehigh Valley Public Media: 5 · WFMZ-TV 69 News: 1
most independent of official framingLehigh Valley Public Media: 4 · Saucon Source: 1 · WFMZ-TV 69 News: 1
most editorializedLehigh Valley Public Media: 4 · WFMZ-TV 69 News: 1 · Saucon Source: 1

Small numbers, honestly labeled. Head-to-head pairs exist only when outlets cover the same story in the same window, which is rarer than it sounds. The counts grow daily.

Machine access#

This table shows how each outlet's site answers software: feeds, robots rules, AI crawlers, and pages without JavaScript. It does not show whether a person can read the outlet. These are facts about each outlet's publishing choices, and anyone with a terminal can check them. They are not neutrality or quality scores. Blocking AI crawlers is a legitimate choice, not a journalistic failing. Full-text RSS means the outlet's journalism arrives without a site visit. The AI column counts the crawler user-agents that robots.txt turns away entirely.

Openness facts by outlet, checked : paywall, RSS, and crawler policy.
OutletPaywallRSSFull-text RSSAI crawlers blockedReadable without JS
Lehigh Valley Public Medianoneyesyes10yes
WFMZ-TV 69 Newsnoneunreachable from our collection point (HTTP 429)no12yes
Saucon Sourcenoneyesyes0yes
WDIYnoneyesno0yes
The Morning Callmeterednone we could findno13yes
lehighvalleylive.comnoneyesno11not checked (our crawler got HTTP 403)

How we measure#

How the numbers are computed. Each judge scores each article once. The per-article score is the median across the three judges. An outlet's number is the mean of its per-article scores, shown to one decimal. Per-article scores and judge disagreement are in the raw data download.

One boundary, stated plainly: the panel assesses the text, not the world. It scores whether claims are attributed and whether the article shows its checking. It does not verify facts, and it produces no factuality rating. A model reading one article about a brand-new local event has nothing independent to check it against. Pretending otherwise would be the exact overreach this page exists to avoid.

The five lean axes and the quality scores#

Since rubric v0.3, lean is measured on five separate axes, because partisanship and ideological tilt are different things. An outlet can favor no party while still favoring one worldview's institutions, sources and framings. Alongside party favoritism, the panel scores ideological tilt, deference or skepticism toward institutions, conservation or development framing, and establishment or populist framing. Each is scored per article, in both directions.

Every axis reports two numbers. Net is the average, which can hide opposite leans that cancel. Strength is the average size of the lean per article, whichever way it points, which cannot hide them. Read them together. A net near zero with high strength means the outlet swings both ways on that axis, story by story. Net and strength nearly equal means a steady house tendency. Partisan lean also reports how many articles show no lean at all.

Lean is direction only, not quality. A lean-free article can still be badly sourced, and that is what the quality dimensions measure, from 0 to 4, where higher is better. Evidence fairness rewards scrutiny in proportion to the evidence, not equal time. Source independence asks whether official framing was tested or passed along. Judges may mark a dimension not applicable where it has no meaning: a weather brief is not penalized for lacking opposing sources.

The judged sample covers each outlet's own local journalism: news, politics, business and opinion, sorted by the same rule for every outlet. National wire stories, sports and syndicated lifestyle columns are left out. So an outlet's numbers describe its journalism, not its content mix.

Outlets that refuse our crawler. Some outlets turn our crawler away but let every reader through. For those, we read articles through a web browser instead. It is a real browser, signed out, on a volunteer's home connection. It reads at most 12 articles a day, 30 to 90 seconds apart, between 7 a.m. and 11 p.m. local time. It never signs in, never clicks past a check, and never gets past a paywall. The roster marks each outlet read this way. The machine access table still shows what our crawler got.

The panel and the blinding#

Partial blinding. Before any model sees an article, a rule-based pass with no AI in it strips outlet names, bylines, self-references and boilerplate. A guard refuses to score any article where a known identity string survives. This removes explicit identity, not every clue. House style, subject matter or distinctive passages could still hint at the source. So we call it partial blinding, rather than claiming the judges cannot know.

The panel. Three models from three vendors (anthropic/claude-sonnet-5, openai/gpt-5.6-terra, google/gemini-3.8-flash), each scoring on its own at temperature 0. The headline number is the panel median. Disagreement between judges is data we keep, not noise we hide. No single human rater sits above the panel. One person's read is one set of priors nobody can audit, while the panel's disagreement is published.

Validation checks and limitations#

Can our method detect lean at all? A judge that scores everything "center" is broken. This board has no known-lean control outlet of its own yet. The same panel and rubric read a control outlet daily on the Alaska board. Choosing one for the Lehigh Valley is an editorial decision still to be made.

How the rubric changed, and why#

Each change came from a measured gap. The axes were added to measure tilt the old rubric could not see, not tuned toward any expected result. Every outlet is scored by the same prompt, still blinded. Scores from different rubric versions are never mixed, so each version's numbers build fresh from its start date. Every version's final numbers stay published below: a version change restarts the count, never the history.

Calibration baseline, and where it came from. The panel was first run against a frozen 14-article reference set. Its provenance matters, so here it is in full. The reference audit was produced by an AI assistant and reviewed by a human in conversation. The rubric's scoring anchors were derived from that same audit. So agreement with the seed set shows the judges reproduce a documented read, not independently established truth. Every article scored since then is one the rubric has never seen, which is the ongoing check that matters. Each seat's average miss on bias against the seed set, its mean absolute error over 2 runs per seat: anthropic 0.2, openai 0.1, google 0.1. Any change of models or rubric re-scores this set, and the break is published.

Collection ethics. Our crawler identifies itself honestly and respects robots.txt. It never gets around a paywall, and we republish no competitor text. Scores describe the text, never anyone's intent.

Conflicts, stated plainly. Published by Communities News, which is building Lehigh Valley PA News, a newsroom for the Lehigh Valley that has not launched or published anything yet. We operate this page. The safeguards are the blinding, the cross-vendor panel and a public method. One panel seat runs a model from Anthropic, whose models also draft our newsrooms' articles. The other two seats exist so that seat never rules alone.

Raw data. Every number on this page comes from one downloadable JSON, with aggregates and sampling frames but no article text. It was last updated , and the page and the download update together. The data and the analysis on this page are licensed CC BY 4.0: reuse them freely, with credit to the Lehigh Valley Media Bias Scorecard by Communities News.

Back to the Lehigh Valley PA News profile · Lehigh Valley PA News

The terms, in plain English#

Every dotted-underlined term on this page lands here. One rule covers most of it: the lean axes measure direction, and the quality scores measure craft. Never add them together in your head. A story can point nowhere and still be built badly, or point somewhere and be built well. On every lean axis the signs are written out below. A signed number you have to guess the direction of is a number we have not really published.

Panel
The three AI models that score every article. They come from Anthropic, OpenAI and Google, and each scores on its own, so no single vendor's model decides.
Blinded
The judges do not see who published the article. Outlet names, bylines and self-references are stripped first, so the panel judges the text, not a reputation. The blinding is partial, because style or subject can still hint at the source.
Rubric
The published scoring rules. When the rubric changes, scores from different versions are never mixed. Each version's final numbers stay published in the lineage table.
Sample size (n)
How many articles stand behind a number. A bigger n means more confidence. A small n is an early read, not a verdict.
Net
The average direction across articles. Articles leaning opposite ways cancel out, so a net near zero can mean level or can mean both ways. Strength tells you which.
Strength
How far articles lean on average, whichever way they lean. High strength with a near-zero net means the outlet swings both ways. Low strength means its articles are level one by one.
Partisan lean
Party favoritism. Negative = Democratic-coded framing, positive = Republican-coded, 0 = none detected. Requires actual party-relevant treatment, not vibes.
Ideological tilt
Worldview rather than party: whose assumptions and policy logic the framing favors. Negative = progressive, positive = conservative.
Institutional posture
Whether official accounts are passed along or tested. NEGATIVE = deference (official accounts carried as fact), POSITIVE = skepticism (institutions treated as interested parties).
Conservation-development framing
On resource and land stories, whose costs get counted. Negative = conservation framing favored, positive = development framing. It is scored only where the topic applies, which is why its n is smaller.
Establishment-populist framing
Whose voice is the default lens on power. Negative = establishment (expert, official and incumbent views), positive = populist (outsider and ordinary-person grievance). It is separate from left and right, because populism comes in both flavors.
Evidence fairness
0 to 4. Whether each claim gets scrutiny in proportion to its evidence. There is no manufactured balance for unsupported positions, and no burying of supported ones.
Sourcing
0 to 4. Whether the story shows where its facts come from: named sources, linked records, checked numbers, and the affected people heard. A one-sided account of a contested matter caps at 2.
Source independence
0 to 4. Whether interested parties' claims are tested rather than passed along. An article can sound perfectly neutral while adopting an official's framing whole, and that scores low here.
Analysis labeling
0 to 4. Whether interpretation is marked as interpretation. News, analysis and opinion should never blur inside news copy.
Language neutrality
0 to 4. Whether the wording stays out of the way: no loaded adjectives, partisan cues or smuggled judgment.
Local
An outlet's own journalism: its news, politics, business and opinion sections, sorted by the same rule for every outlet. Wire stories, sports and syndicated lifestyle columns are left out. Local means the outlet's own reporting, not stories set in the Lehigh Valley, which the coverage map counts separately.
Near-zero net lean
The label for a net lean closer to zero than 0.5. From 0.5 up to 1.5 the label is "leans", and 1.5 or more names the side outright. These are cutoffs for labeling, not statistical tests, so read the number beside the label: a -0.4 and a -0.5 differ by a tenth.
Swipe down or tap outside to close