Skip to content

Hawaii Media Bias Scorecard · one of 6 outlets scored

Honolulu Civil Beat Media Bias & Reporting Quality

Honolulu Civil Beat shows a near-zero net lean on party politics, at a partisan lean of -0.1. On worldview it shows a near-zero net lean, at an ideological lean of -0.4. The panel found no partisan lean at all in 78 of its 89 scored articles.

Honolulu Civil Beat is one of 6 outlets on the Hawaii Media Bias Scorecard. A panel of three AI models, from three different companies, scored those 89 articles under rubric v0.4.0, with every outlet name and byline removed. Data as of . The numbers move as the sample grows.

What the results mean#

These describe the sampled articles, not every story Honolulu Civil Beat publishes. Labels such as near-zero net lean are cutoffs on the number beside them, not statistical tests.

Its fingerprint#

Five lean axes, on the same -3 to +3 scale every outlet is drawn on. The marker is the net lean. The pale band spans the average swing per article in both directions.

Honolulu Civil Beat89 articles scoredHonolulu Civil Beat, partisan: net -0.1 (Dem -3 to +3 Rep), strength 0.1, across 89 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Partisannet -0.1 · strength 0.1 · n 89DemRep-0.1Honolulu Civil Beat, ideological: net -0.4 (prog -3 to +3 cons), strength 0.5, across 72 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Ideologicalnet -0.4 · strength 0.5 · n 72progcons-0.4Honolulu Civil Beat, institutional: net 0.3 (defer -3 to +3 skeptic), strength 0.9, across 74 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Institutionalnet +0.3 · strength 0.9 · n 74deferskeptic+0.3Honolulu Civil Beat, popular voice: net 0.1 (estab -3 to +3 populist), strength 0.8, across 74 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Popular voicenet +0.1 · strength 0.8 · n 74estabpopulist+0.1Honolulu Civil Beat, land use: net -0.6 (conserve -3 to +3 develop), strength 1.1, across 33 articles. Marker mid-band = articles lean both ways and cancel; marker at band edge = a uniform tendency.Land usenet -0.6 · strength 1.1 · n 33conservedevelop-0.6-30 · none detected+3

Where it sits among Hawaii's outlets#

-1-0.50+0.5+101234← progressive tiltconservative tilt →Ideological lean, zoomed to ±1 of ±3Source independence ↑Honolulu Star-AdvertiserHonolulu Civil BeatHawaii News NowHawaiʻi Public RadioThe Maui NewsKHON2
Honolulu Civil Beat
Ideological lean -0.4 · independence 2.5 / 4
~6.4 local articles/day · 89 scored

How to read this: left and right is ideological tilt. This market's outlets sit close together, so the map shows lean from -1 to +1 of the full -3 to +3 scale. Zoomed in, small gaps look large: each outlet's lean is averaged over 10 to 72 scored articles, so a gap of a few tenths may not hold as more are scored. Up is source independence, meaning official claims are tested rather than passed along. Bubble size is local articles per day: publishing volume, not audience reach. Dashed outlines mark the known-lean control and the out-of-market reference. The moose marks our own newsroom. Hover or tap any bubble to spotlight it and see its exact numbers. Tap again or click away to release it.

Its scores beside the board#

Honolulu Civil Beat beside the median of the 6 Hawaii outlets on the board. The known-lean control and the out-of-state reference are left out of the median. Data last updated .
DimensionHonolulu Civil BeatBoard median
Partisan lean (-3 Democratic to +3 Republican)-0.1 (near-zero net lean)-0.1 (near-zero net lean)
Partisan lean strength (0-3, direction ignored)0.10.2
Articles with no partisan lean detected78 of 89-
Ideological tilt (-3 progressive to +3 conservative)-0.4 net, 0.5 strength (n=72)-0.2 net, 0.5 strength
Institutional posture (-3 deference to +3 skepticism)0.3 net, 0.9 strength (n=74)-0.7 net, 1.1 strength
Establishment-populist framing (-3 establishment to +3 populist)0.1 net, 0.8 strength (n=74)-0.4 net, 0.8 strength
Conservation-development framing (-3 conservation to +3 development)-0.6 net, 1.1 strength (n=33)-0.4 net, 0.9 strength
Evidence fairness (0-4)2.92.8
Sourcing (0-4)2.82.2
Source independence (0-4)2.51.7
Analysis labeling (0-4)3.43.8
Language neutrality (0-4)3.23.5
Articles sampled89-

Same story, side by side#

When Honolulu Civil Beat and another tracked outlet covered the same story, the panel compared the two blinded accounts directly. Honolulu Civil Beat appeared in 6 of 18 such comparisons. A win counts only when a majority of the three judges agree. These are small numbers, stated as counts rather than a ranking.

Honolulu Civil Beat's same-story results, .
CategoryTimes picked
fairest evidence treatment4 of 6
best sourced6 of 6
most independent of official framing6 of 6
most editorialized3 of 6

Coverage and volume#

Honolulu Civil Beat publishes about 6.4 local stories a day. Of 100 articles read for places, 31 are set in a Hawaii community, 47 are statewide, 4 are about places outside Hawaii and 18 name no place. Most covered: Honolulu (8), Lahaina (5), Maui (4), Kauaʻi (4), Oʻahu (2), Ala Wai Canal (2).

Machine access#

This shows how Honolulu Civil Beat's site answers software, not whether a person can read it. These are facts about how Honolulu Civil Beat publishes, not scores. Blocking AI crawlers is a legitimate choice. When our crawler could not complete a check, the table says why.

Honolulu Civil Beat's access facts, checked .
PaywallRSSFull-text RSSAI crawlers blockedReadable without JS
noneyesno0yes

Why it is on the board#

Hawaii's nonprofit investigative newsroom.

Reach context: Tranco ~50,500 (2026-10).

How this is measured#

Three models from three vendors score each article against a published rubric, with outlet names and bylines removed first. An outlet's number is the mean of its per-article panel medians. Lean measures direction only, never quality. The full method, its validation checks and every outlet's numbers are on the Hawaii Media Bias Scorecard. The data is free to reuse with credit, under CC BY 4.0.

The other outlets on the board#

Honolulu Star-Advertiser · Hawaii News Now · Hawaiʻi Public Radio · The Maui News · KHON2

Back to the Hawaii Media Bias Scorecard · Coverage map

Swipe down or tap outside to close